A closer look · Original illustrative demo
What makes feedback
worth acting on?
A specific observation. A reason it matters. A change you can consider. Here’s how that looks for a fictional studio landing page.
This sample uses an original fictional design and editorially written feedback. It demonstrates the kind of critique to look for; it is not a customer testimonial or a live AI-generated report.
First fix · Make the promise specific
“Spaces for what’s next” leaves the service unclear. Name the work and who it’s for.
- Audience
- Independent café owners
- Goal
- Start a conversation about an interiors project
- Context
- First visit, from a recommendation
Three changes to consider
-
01
Say what you do, before how it feels.
The headline could belong to an architect, a coworking space, or a furniture brand.
Try: “Thoughtful interiors for independent cafés.” Put the service and customer in the first line.
-
02
Give the visitor one clear next step.
Three matching buttons give the studio, portfolio, and enquiry the same priority.
Try: Make “Discuss your café” the primary action. Keep “See our work” as a quieter link.
-
03
Connect the image to a real project.
An attractive image sets a mood, but gives no context for evaluating the work.
Try: Add a short project caption: the type of space, what changed, and the studio’s role. Use only facts you can support.
Why the context matters
The same page.
A different job to do.
If this studio wanted to attract design collaborators, showing the studio’s point of view might deserve more prominence. For café owners deciding whether to enquire, the service, relevant work, and next step need to be clear first.
That is why Crit asks about the audience and goal before it reviews the work. The suggested changes should serve the intended reader, not an abstract score.
What this example cannot establish
A static image cannot prove that the page is accessible, usable, or converting well. Test the actual page with people, check interactions and accessibility, and compare feedback with your own constraints.
Before the next review
Give the work
another look.
Get 3 free critiques
Free download for iPhone and iPad. Optional Pro subscription.